Voters and political observers are questioning Zohran Mamdani’s credibility as the Democratic nominee for New York City mayor following his reversal on long-held policy positions. Previously, Mamdani advocated defunding the police, decriminalizing prostitution, and abolishing prisons. He now says these stances are “out of step” with his current campaign.
During a recent interview with Errol Louis, Mamdani repeatedly sidestepped direct questions. When asked about the role of School Safety Agents in city schools, he launched into a broad critique of the social services system instead of providing a clear answer. Analysts described his explanations as “word salad,” mealy-mouthed, and lacking substance. Observers also noted that his discussion of the proposed Department of Community Safety offered no concrete details on implementation.
Mamdani has been pressed about his 2020 social media posts, in which he labeled the NYPD “racist, anti-queer & a major threat to public safety” and urged: “Defund it. Dismantle it. End the cycle of violence.” He confirmed his views have shifted, but critics argue that his current assurances do not guarantee he would not revisit past positions if elected.
Mayor Eric Adams highlighted his achievements in reducing crime and warned that placing Mamdani in charge could compromise the safety of all New Yorkers. Observers say Mamdani’s evasive answers and repeated policy shifts reflect political opportunism rather than consistent, reliable leadership.
Attempts to appeal to moderates and independents have followed his primary victory, but opponents contend the candidate’s lack of clear answers underscores ongoing concerns about his reliability and consistency.
